Best Substitute for Evaporated Milk

The best swap

Half-and-half

Swap it cup for cup. To make the real thing, simmer 2¼ cups of milk gently until reduced to 1 cup, about 25 minutes.

Evaporated milk is milk with about 60 percent of the water cooked out. It is creamy without being as fatty as cream, and it is unsweetened.

All the substitutes for evaporated milk, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Half-and-half1 cupThe same creaminess with no cooking. The easiest swap.
Milk, reduced2¼ cups simmered down to 1 cupExactly what the can contains.
Heavy cream1 cupRicher. Good in pumpkin pie, soups and sauces.
Whole milk1 cupIn a pinch for baking. The result is a little thinner and less rich.
Dry milk powder⅔ cup powder + ¾ cup waterMilk powder mixed at double strength.
Full-fat coconut milk1 cupDairy-free. Works well in pumpkin pie and curries.

What not to use

Sweetened condensed milk. It is nearly half sugar and will ruin a savory dish or oversweeten a pie.

More substitutes

Cream CheeseRicottaGreek YogurtBrown SugarPowdered SugarCorn SyrupHoneyMaple Syrup