Best Substitute for Molasses

The best swap

Dark corn syrup, honey or maple syrup

Swap any of them cup for cup. The flavor will be milder and the color lighter.

Molasses gives gingerbread, baked beans and brown bread their dark color and bittersweet depth. Nothing matches it exactly, but several syrups come close enough.

All the substitutes for molasses, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Dark corn syrup1 cupThe closest in color and thickness.
Honey1 cupSweeter and lighter in flavor.
Maple syrup1 cupThinner. Good in baked beans and glazes.
Dark brown sugar¾ cup packed + ¼ cup hot waterBrown sugar already contains molasses, so the flavor is right.
Sorghum syrup or black treacle1 cupThe nearest in flavor, if you can find them.

What not to use

Blackstrap molasses in place of regular molasses. It is far more bitter and less sweet.

More substitutes

Cake FlourBread FlourSelf-Rising FlourCornstarchBaking PowderBaking SodaCream of TartarYeast