Best Substitute for Tahini
The best swap
Smooth cashew or almond butter
Swap it cup for cup. Use an unsweetened, unsalted nut butter and loosen it with a little water if it is stiff.
Tahini is ground sesame seeds: nutty, slightly bitter and very creamy. In hummus and dressings it supplies richness as much as flavor.
All the substitutes for tahini, ranked
| Substitute | How much | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Cashew or almond butter | Same amount | Milder and slightly sweeter. Makes very smooth hummus. |
| Sunflower seed butter | Same amount | Nut-free, and the nearest to tahini’s earthy flavor. |
| Natural peanut butter | ¾ of the amount | Stronger flavor. Fine in dressings and noodle sauces. |
| Toasted sesame oil | 1 tbsp per ¼ cup tahini, plus 3 tbsp Greek yogurt or olive oil | Brings the sesame flavor without the body. |
| Homemade tahini | 1 cup toasted sesame seeds + 3 tbsp neutral oil, blended 5 minutes | Better than most jars. |

