Best Substitute for Tahini

The best swap

Smooth cashew or almond butter

Swap it cup for cup. Use an unsweetened, unsalted nut butter and loosen it with a little water if it is stiff.

Tahini is ground sesame seeds: nutty, slightly bitter and very creamy. In hummus and dressings it supplies richness as much as flavor.

All the substitutes for tahini, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Cashew or almond butterSame amountMilder and slightly sweeter. Makes very smooth hummus.
Sunflower seed butterSame amountNut-free, and the nearest to tahini’s earthy flavor.
Natural peanut butter¾ of the amountStronger flavor. Fine in dressings and noodle sauces.
Toasted sesame oil1 tbsp per ¼ cup tahini, plus 3 tbsp Greek yogurt or olive oilBrings the sesame flavor without the body.
Homemade tahini1 cup toasted sesame seeds + 3 tbsp neutral oil, blended 5 minutesBetter than most jars.

Recipes that use tahini

More substitutes

White WineRed WineChicken BrothSoy SauceWorcestershire SauceTomato PasteLemon JuiceApple Cider Vinegar