Best Substitute for Parmesan

The best swap

Pecorino Romano or Grana Padano

Swap either cup for cup. Pecorino is saltier and sharper, so cut back the salt. Grana Padano is the closest match and usually costs less.

Parmesan is a hard, aged cheese: salty, nutty and full of savory flavor. Other hard aged cheeses behave the same way when grated and melted.

All the substitutes for parmesan, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Grana PadanoSame amountNearly identical, slightly milder.
Pecorino RomanoSame amount, less saltMade from sheep’s milk. Sharper. Classic in carbonara.
Aged AsiagoSame amountNutty and a little sweeter.
Aged Manchego or dry JackSame amountGood for grating over pasta and salads.
Nutritional yeastHalf the amountVegan. Adds savory flavor but does not melt.
Toasted garlic breadcrumbsSame amountFor a crunchy topping on pasta, when there is no cheese at all.

What not to use

Pre-grated Parmesan from a shaker in a sauce. The anti-caking powder stops it melting, and the sauce turns grainy.

Recipes that use parmesan

More substitutes

MayonnaiseDijon MustardShorteningVegetable OilKosher SaltFresh HerbsGarlicEggs