Best Substitute for Shortening

The best swap

Butter, using a little more

For 1 cup of shortening, use 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons of butter. Butter is about 80 percent fat, while shortening is all fat.

Shortening is pure fat that is solid at room temperature and has no flavor. It makes cookies tall and soft and pie crusts tender. Butter does the same work with better flavor, though cookies spread a little more.

All the substitutes for shortening, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Butter1 cup + 2 tbsp per cupBetter flavor. Chill cookie dough before baking to limit spreading.
Lard7/8 cup per cupMakes the flakiest pie crust and biscuits.
Refined coconut oil1 cupSolid at room temperature and neutral in flavor. Use it firm, not melted.
Stick margarine1 cupBehaves much like butter.
Vegetable oil¾ cup per cupOnly where the shortening is melted, and for frying. Not for pie crust or creamed cookies.

More substitutes

Vegetable OilKosher SaltFresh HerbsGarlicEggsButterMilkAll-Purpose Flour