Best Substitute for Butter

The best swap

Salted butter, or stick margarine

Swap either one cup for cup. With salted butter, leave out ¼ teaspoon of salt for each ½ cup (1 stick).

Butter is about 80 percent fat and 16 percent water, and it is solid when cool. That matters in baking: creamed butter traps air, and cold butter makes flaky layers. Solid fats can replace it anywhere. Liquid oils only work where the butter is melted.

All the substitutes for butter, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Salted for unsaltedSame amount, minus ¼ tsp salt per stickNo other change needed.
Stick margarine or plant-based butter sticksSame amountCreams and bakes like butter. Use sticks, not tubs.
Refined coconut oilSame amountSolid at room temperature. Cookies come out slightly crisper.
ShorteningSame amount + a pinch of saltCookies spread less and stay softer, with less flavor.
Vegetable or olive oil¾ cup per cup of butterOnly in recipes that use melted butter: muffins, quick breads, brownies.
Unsweetened applesauceReplace up to half the butterLower in fat. Softer and more cake-like.
GheeSame amountFor cooking and sautéing. Handles higher heat than butter.

Recipes that use butter

More substitutes

MilkAll-Purpose FlourButtermilkHeavy CreamSour CreamHalf-and-HalfSweetened Condensed MilkEvaporated Milk