Best Substitute for Sweetened Condensed Milk
The best swap
Milk simmered with sugar
To replace one 14-oz can, simmer 2 cups of whole milk with ¾ cup of sugar over low heat, stirring often, until thick and reduced by half: about 40 minutes. It thickens more as it cools.
Sweetened condensed milk is milk with most of the water removed and a lot of sugar added. That combination makes fudge set, pies thicken and no-churn ice cream stay soft, so a substitute has to be both thick and sweet.
All the substitutes for sweetened condensed milk, ranked
| Substitute | How much | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Whole milk + sugar, reduced | 2 cups milk + ¾ cup sugar, simmered to about 1¼ cups | The real thing, made at home. |
| Evaporated milk + sugar | One 12-oz can + 1½ cups sugar, heated until dissolved | Fast, because the milk is already reduced. Makes more than one can’s worth. |
| Coconut milk + sugar | One 13.5-oz can full-fat coconut milk + ⅓ cup sugar, simmered 30 minutes | Dairy-free. Light coconut flavor. |
| Cream of coconut | 1 cup per can | Already thick and sweet. Good in bars and pies. |
| Dry milk powder | 1 cup powder + ⅔ cup sugar + ⅓ cup boiling water + 3 tbsp butter, blended | A pantry version. Blend until smooth and chill to thicken. |
What not to use
Evaporated milk straight from the can. It looks similar but has no sugar and is far thinner.
