Best Substitute for Sweetened Condensed Milk

The best swap

Milk simmered with sugar

To replace one 14-oz can, simmer 2 cups of whole milk with ¾ cup of sugar over low heat, stirring often, until thick and reduced by half: about 40 minutes. It thickens more as it cools.

Sweetened condensed milk is milk with most of the water removed and a lot of sugar added. That combination makes fudge set, pies thicken and no-churn ice cream stay soft, so a substitute has to be both thick and sweet.

All the substitutes for sweetened condensed milk, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Whole milk + sugar, reduced2 cups milk + ¾ cup sugar, simmered to about 1¼ cupsThe real thing, made at home.
Evaporated milk + sugarOne 12-oz can + 1½ cups sugar, heated until dissolvedFast, because the milk is already reduced. Makes more than one can’s worth.
Coconut milk + sugarOne 13.5-oz can full-fat coconut milk + ⅓ cup sugar, simmered 30 minutesDairy-free. Light coconut flavor.
Cream of coconut1 cup per canAlready thick and sweet. Good in bars and pies.
Dry milk powder1 cup powder + ⅔ cup sugar + ⅓ cup boiling water + 3 tbsp butter, blendedA pantry version. Blend until smooth and chill to thicken.

What not to use

Evaporated milk straight from the can. It looks similar but has no sugar and is far thinner.

More substitutes

Evaporated MilkCream CheeseRicottaGreek YogurtBrown SugarPowdered SugarCorn SyrupHoney