Best Substitute for Half-and-Half

The best swap

Whole milk plus heavy cream

For 1 cup of half-and-half, mix ¾ cup of whole milk with ¼ cup of heavy cream.

Half-and-half is simply milk and cream mixed to about 12 percent fat. If you have either of those, you can make it.

All the substitutes for half-and-half, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Whole milk + heavy cream¾ cup milk + ¼ cup creamIdentical to the real thing.
Whole milk + melted butter1 tbsp melted butter, then milk to make 1 cupFor cooking and baking. Not for coffee.
Evaporated milk1 cupWorks in soups, sauces, quiche and coffee.
Whole milk1 cupFine in most baking and in coffee. Sauces will be a little thinner.
Heavy cream + water½ cup cream + ½ cup waterWhen cream is all you have.

More substitutes

Sweetened Condensed MilkEvaporated MilkCream CheeseRicottaGreek YogurtBrown SugarPowdered SugarCorn Syrup