Best Substitute for Vanilla Extract

The best swap

Vanilla bean paste, or maple syrup from the pantry

Swap either one teaspoon for teaspoon.

Vanilla rounds out and deepens other flavors. In most baking a teaspoon or two is background, so a substitute only needs to add a little warmth and sweetness.

All the substitutes for vanilla extract, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Vanilla bean paste1 tspThe same flavor, plus the specks.
Vanilla beanSeeds of ⅓ bean per 1 tsp extractThe best flavor of all. Save the pod for vanilla sugar.
Maple syrup1 tspThe best pantry swap. Warm and sweet, and unnoticeable in baking.
Bourbon, rum or brandy1 tspVanilla extract is mostly alcohol, so these behave the same.
Almond extract½ tspMuch stronger and a different flavor. Good in sugar cookies and cakes.
Imitation vanilla1 tspIn baked goods, few people can tell the difference.
NothingLeave it outIn chocolate or heavily spiced recipes you will barely notice.

Recipes that use vanilla extract

More substitutes

Pumpkin Pie SpiceChili PowderTahiniWhite WineRed WineChicken BrothSoy SauceWorcestershire Sauce