Best Substitute for Shallots

The best swap

Yellow onion with a pinch of garlic

For 1 medium shallot, use ¼ cup of finely chopped yellow or sweet onion and a small pinch of minced garlic.

Shallots taste like a mild, sweet onion with a hint of garlic, and they melt into sauces. Measure the swap by volume, not by count: one small onion equals about three shallots.

All the substitutes for shallots, ranked

SubstituteHow muchGood to know
Yellow or sweet onion + garlic¼ cup chopped onion + pinch of garlic per shallotBest for cooked dishes. Chop it finely.
Red onion¼ cup chopped per shallotBest for raw uses such as dressings. Soak in cold water for 10 minutes to soften the bite.
Scallions, white parts3 scallions per shallotMild and quick-cooking.
Leeks, white part⅓ cup sliced per shallotSweet and delicate. Good in sauces and soups.
Chives1 tbsp choppedFor garnish only.

Recipes that use shallots

More substitutes

BreadcrumbsParmesanMayonnaiseDijon MustardShorteningVegetable OilKosher SaltFresh Herbs